The Great Circumcision Debate

Dear Minister Aaron Motsoaledi

Everybody writes an open letter these days so now it’s my turn. Your speech at the Cosatu conference, shows that you continue to back medical circumcisions in areas hard- hit by HIV.

But the word “medical circumcisions” is somewhat of a dirty word among rural doctors I’ve met. As a journalist interested in rural health, I have been living next door to Mosvold hospital, in the far northern reaches of rural KwaZulu-Natal, to get the down low on what is really going on.

When speaking to doctors here about their work, it’s almost inevitable that medical circumcisions will come up in conversation. Some doctors are violently opposed to the practice, well not violently. They do the procedure a hundred times a day without harming the man’s jewels but they would rather not be in theatre doing one simple operation after the other. Others are more positive quoting the research that shows circumcisions do reduce the risk of contracting HIV.

Doctors against medical circumcisions say that many a circumcised rural man has expressed the belief that they are far less likely to contract HIV, if at all and are hoping to get involved with more women using fewer condoms.

Healthcare workers don’t speak to the media on the record because it is up to the Department of Health spokesperson, but let’s hear from the Canadian doctor Mary Toulson who isn’t worried about protocol. She worked at KwaZulu Natal’s Mosvold hospital till the end of June this year.

“I hate medical circumcisions,” she says with passion. This is because Toulson has too often been approached by patients asking for a circumcision because “they want more sex.”

Toulson also feels the circumcision camps place additional burdens on Mosvold, a short-staffed rural hospital. Rural hospitals in KwaZulu-Natal are typically short-staffed. The operations that take place three times a week make work even more hectic for Mosvold’s nine soon-to-be-seven full time doctors who serve an estimated 150 000 patients.

When increasing rural staff’s workloads with hundreds of circumcisions a week, it is worth thinking about medical staff retention in rural areas. I mean it’s where just over forty percent of the population lives but where only just over ten percent of the all doctors that graduate each year go to work, according to Medical Recruitment NGO Africa Health Placements.

Dr Toulson says there have been days that so many doctors were doing circumcisions that other patients suffered. There were times when she worked in the Outpatient’s Department and couldn’t find a spare nurse to translate for her and help her understand her Zulu patients. This was because too many nurses where busy in theatre with circumcisions. Dr Lungile Hobe, at nearby Msileni Hospital, was far more positive about circumcisions, so it’s a not a clear cut issue but one that bears looking into before mass circumcision roll outs.

If one takes a walk through Mosvold hospital on a Monday, Wednesday or Friday one will see men and boys in blue gowns, usually reserved for the sick and weak, waiting for the great circumcision operation. Or perhaps, if they have gone wondering looking for the bathroom, one will catch sight of their naked buttocks because the theatre gowns leave a little more exposed than they should. They wait on a bench in a line and walk into theatre one by one with a brave look on their faces and fear in their eyes.

My translator and I chatted to a few about why they were being circumcised.
One teenager who just gave his name as Sipho said he was definitely going to have lots of girlfriends when he was well or when his-soon-to-be circumcised part was well.

Then there was the little 13-year-old who took his penis in his hand and explained that he was having a circumcision so he could wash his manhood in the bath with less trouble and keep it clean. He did a little display for us and I was happy the hospital gown kept things a little less obscene.

I was relieved to hear the text book answer, “It reduces HIV infections but I will still wear a condom,” from 21-year-old Stembiso Nxumalo who I later learned was a nursing student at Mosvold. He admitted to me post-op, when he told me it was still sore and swollen, (didn’t need to know) that plenty of rural boys don’t understand the operation and feel they are invincible afterwards.

It’s not all men who think they are suddenly being given a magic operation to prevent them from contracting HIV but Dr Touslon is not alone in saying that she has heard too many men asking for the operation with the idea of getting a lot more action once they have been snipped.

The Health Department needs to be aware that when medical circumcisions are done on a mass scale – doctors don’t have much time to explain to the men what circumcision is actually about. It is concerning that those on the front line say the mass roll out of circumcisions is encouraging promiscuity. And from a nurse, saying yes there are rural men in his community who get completely the wrong idea. It is certainly contributing to staff dissatisfaction among overworked doctors in a remote area where there are chronic doctor shortages.

Umbrella medical organisation, The Rural Health Advocacy Project’s manager Marije Versteeg says she doesn’t know of any research into whether medical circumcisions are confusing the HIV message, but would love to hear of some.

So while this mass roll out of the giant snip snip continues, how about asking some doctors in Northern KwaZulu Natal, where it is happening every few days, what they think or more importantly what the patients think.

Posted with WordPress for BlackBerry.

About Kat child

I am a journalist (big smile: I love saying that) and a coffee lover. I believe journalism should tell untold stories and give a voice to the voiceless. I love Cape Town, the beach, cheese, chocolate and Origin's cappucinos. I don't see the point of making one's bed and I wear odd socks.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to The Great Circumcision Debate

  1. dick pantalone says:

    just discovered our blog very well done
    i wil be working at Ngwalazane hospital in the near future for at least a year(geneal surgeon, hand surgeon), hopefully much longer my gilfriend is coming but at present does not hve a job although she would like to teach Has been the head of a large chmistery lab at a hospital in us for many years but wants a change . she is also concerned about security issues and feels taht white woman such as she are often treated with disdain or contempt( per our recent vacation to SA) could you give her words of encouragement?? I would also loe to correspond with you Keep up the good journalism, i like your style!
    dick pantalone

  2. … There is a movement of Jews who are questioning circumcision, and working to end this abuse of children. The movement ranges from the Orthodox to the secular, and includes mothers, fathers, scholars, historians, medical professionals, activists, and intellectuals.

    Jewish Groups for Genital Integrity

    * Brit Shalom Celebrants by Mark D. Reiss, M.D. http://www.circumstitions.com/Jewish-shalom.html

    * Questioning Circumcision: A Jewish Perspective by Ron Goldman, Ph.D. http://www.jewishcircumcision.org

    * The Current Judaic Movement to End Circumcision: Part 1
    http://intactnews.org/node/105/1311886372/jewish-voices-current-judaic-movement-end-circumcision-part-1

    Circumcision: A Jewish Feminist Perspective by Miriam Pollack
    http://www.noharmm.org/pollack.htm

    Jewish Intactivist Miriam Pollack has some great commentary on Foreskin Man in this recent interview.
    http://www.beyondthebris.com/2011/07/defying-convention-interview-with_27.html

    Jews Speak Out in Favor of Banning Circumcision on Minors
    http://intactnews.org/node/103/1311885181/jews-speak-out-favor-banning-circumcision-minors

  3. Alex says:

    This is pretty irresponsible “journalism” . Nobody in the HIV/AIDS prevention community is suggesting that circumcision means you don’t still have to practice safe sex and use condoms. Behavior change is still critical. Clearly, if your reporting is to be trusted, there’s not enough of it in KZN. But the empirical data is clear – the reduction in HIV transmission rates among effectively circumcised adult males is above 60%. That is as close to a vaccine as we have right now. To abandon its mass scale-up because of some obstinate cultural relativism or because of a few bad eggs who think it’s OK to use it as an excuse to get busy with more women is to let the least common denominators decide the survival rates of a generation of South Africans. Let’s hope Minister Motsoaledi sticks to his far more enlightened position.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s